← Toutes les offres
M

Nobody gets to tell you that your good experiences are bad, actually

MichaelDickens

Global
Publié le 16 novembre 2026

Description du poste

I know my life is good because I'm the one living it. In the same spirit as Descartes' "I think, therefore I am", I have greater certainty about the goodness of my experiences than I do about any fact about the external world. Some theories of population ethics deny this. Average utilitarianism might say: Hey Michael, I know you're happy, but other people are happier than you, so it would be better for you not to exist. The experiences you think are good are actually bad, because they're not good enough. To that, I say: No, you're wrong, Mister Average Utilitarianism. I'm the one living my life, I can tell how good my experiences are, and you don't get a say in the matter. My good experiences don't turn bad just because other people exist. I am the ultimate judge of the goodness of my experiences.[1] In Why Care About the Moral Law?, Richard Y. Chappell wrote: "Morality should serve the interests of moral subjects, not the other way around."[2] If a theory of ethics says that your good life isn't good after all, then how is that theory serving your interests? And you're the one who experiences that goodness, not anyone else, so how can that theory be serving anyone else's interests? Cross-posted from my website. The separability principle If I tell you “I’m torturing an animal in my apartment,” do you go “well, if there are no other animals being tortured anywhere in the world, then that’s really terrible! But there are some, so it’s probably not as terrible. Let me go check how many animals are being tortured.” (a minute later) “Oh, like ten billion. In that case you’re not doing anything morally bad, carry on.” I can’t see why a person’s suffering would be less morally significant depending on how many other people are suffering. —Kelsey Piper[3] (Philosophers sometimes refer to "the Egyptology thought experiment",[4] which conveys the same message, but I like Kelsey's version better.) This is the separability principle: the goodness or badness of a