Description du poste
Cross-posted from maxghenis.com.
Summary
• Eight AI forecasters, four runs of Claude Opus 5.5 and four of GPT-6.1 Sol, expect passage of DC's Initiative 86 to make further farmed-animal measures likelier. On November 3, DC voters decide whether to ban force-feeding birds and selling foie gras and other "fattened bird liver products". Each forecaster researched alone and answered 22 linked questions, and I timestamped the pooled results on October 26.
• To separate what passing does from what a big Yes vote says about voters, I compare the forecasts at a bare pass (50.5% Yes) with those at a bare fail (49.5% Yes). A bare pass raises the chance that someone files a new DC initiative on farmed animals or animal products by the end of 2028 from 22% to 31%. It raises the chance of another DC law restricting farmed-animal treatment or animal-product sales by the end of 2030 from 20% to 25%. Across all failing and passing margins, the gaps widen (18% against 45% for a new initiative), and a bare pass accounts for about a fifth to a third of each.
• Beyond DC, a bare pass raises the chance that Pro-Animal Future, the advocacy group behind the DC campaign, qualifies a 2028 statewide measure on chickens, pigs, cattle or fish from 10% to 13%. It leaves the chance that federal law preempts sales standards like California's Proposition 12 by the end of 2030 near 29%.
• The two models agree on the measure's chances and on what a bare pass does to the odds of a new DC initiative. If the measure passes, though, every run of one model gives a higher forecast than every run of the other on 15 of the 22 questions. For another DC law restricting farmed-animal treatment or animal-product sales, the Sol runs give 50% to 61% if the measure passes, and the Opus runs 15% to 23%.
• The forecasters put the measure's chance of passing at 89.7%. If it passes, they put the chance that the sale ban stands on December 1, 2028, with a funding certification from DC's chief financial officer, at 57