Description du poste
TL;DR: I think embedding new technologies in our lives too fast, and without analogue alternatives, could lead us towards an unrecoverable dystopia. I share my observations and concerns in this post and look forward to reading your views on AI’s impact on your community or surroundings. I use “AI” as an all-encompassing term for chatbots and generative models.
[Transition risks] arise during a transition to a new technological or social regime. [...] Rushing the transition may do nothing to lower these risks—indeed it could easily heighten them. But if the transition is necessary or highly desirable, we may have to go through it at some point, so mere delay is not a solution, and may also make things worse. The general prescription for these risks is neither haste nor slowness, but care and foresight. (Ord, 2020: 209)
I am in The Precipice reading group, and it gave me a new lens through which to look at the increasing entrenchment of tech in our lives. To me, the rapid adoption of AI is a transition risk. Some use cases and early studies show risks to cognitive capacities and communities. Meanwhile opting out from AI use is already penalised in some fields, and we are running towards making it quasi-impossible.
Ord’s quote, from the book, reflects my worry. This transition is happening too fast, without knowledge about its future social consequences, that go well beyond job displacement. I am afraid we are making ourselves dependent on technology, as a systemic practical obligation.
In an AI-first future, cognitive decay may be widespread because of AI dependency. First because of the deployment of applications in all areas of life, and second because AI natives will grow up without alternatives. To me, it fits Ord’s unrecoverable dystopia and the second category of Bostrom’s flawed realisation: the ephemeral realisation, where mature technological development starts by providing value, but degenerates because it is unsustainable.
In terms of scale, I think it cou