Description du poste
TL;DR: Numerical weights can very efficiently communicate how you are disposed to adjudicate a wide range of tradeoffs. Stating a threshold reveals your trade-off rates much as betting odds reveal credences.
The recent charity discourse has highlighted some common pathologies in how people judge and respond to quantitative moral reasoning. In particular:
• Many mistakenly assume that numbers represent a claim to objective certainty.• Many are inordinately offended by seeing numbers assigned on the basis of “subjective” judgment calls. (Some judgments may still be better than others, of course; in calling the process “subjective” I don’t mean to imply that there’s no truth of the matter.)• Many are inordinately offended by what they perceive as “false precision”.The common mistake appears to be a failure to appreciate that numbers can serve to represent our best guess about how to weigh a factor in a trade-off. Others might reasonably make different judgment calls (which can be represented by different numbers), and that’s fine. There’s simply no implication that one’s best-guess number is the only possible answer.[1]
Pulling Numbers Out of Thin AirPerhaps the most sophisticated proponent of this objection is Harvard’s Sasha Gusev, who repeatedly pressed:
Dario just pulled these numbers out of thin air… Sure, many people just operate on vibes, but what Dario is doing here is also just a vibe and then assigning an arbitrary number to it. That’s even worse, because it makes vibes seem analytical… That’s bad and EAs shouldn’t defend it.
I disagree! Sasha seems to be assuming that numbers are only allowed to be the results of a calculation, not an input or premise. But that’s clearly wrong. Dario’s number explicitly represents his judgment call about how to adjudicate the tradeoff in question, and judgment calls about tradeoffs are unavoidable. It’s positively helpful to communicate one’s judgment calls with numbers: it conveys more information about how he’d weigh diffe