Description du poste
Subtitle: Weighing Infant Deaths When Donating Is Not Beyond the Pale
I think most people have pretty badly misguided moral priorities, which is tricky to argue without making them defensive. (Today I’m going to prioritize clarity, despite this cost.) I generally try to thread the needle by being pretty lax about our positive moral obligations (it’s great to do good, but we all do less than would be ideal, so it would seem a bit unreasonable to hold that against anyone). But I feel much more strongly about (i) the negative obligation to do no harm, violated by those villains who go out of their way to discourage others from doing good effectively, and (ii) our intellectual obligations to try to figure out what’s true, and appreciate better actions whether or not we’re willing to pursue them ourselves. Combining these, I am especially appalled by people who discourage weighing tradeoffs or thinking carefully about the good. I find that behavior so vile, it literally makes my skin crawl.
So I’ve found it very depressing to witness the viral online reaction to a snippet of the recent NY Times profile of Dario Amodei which mentions his guest blog post for GiveWell, as a graduate student in 2010, reasoning carefully about where to donate $10,000 of his grad student stipend. I think this is just about the epitome of moral and intellectual virtue; I doubt many of his critics have done anything nearly so virtuous in their entire lives. Yet the online reaction showed people reacting to this virtue by calling him “a piece of shit”, “arrogant”, “monstrous”, etc. — all because one factor in his reasoning is that he gives 2-3x more weight to saving adults than infants (due to differences in cognitive development).1
It’s difficult to articulate (without cursing) how deeply messed up I find this. Two points I especially want to emphasize:
(1) How to weigh fetal vs infant vs mature human interests in avoiding death is a difficult, deeply contestable question about which people can