Description du poste
TL;DR: We lack high-quality evidence on what reduces animal product consumption, and I see current academic incentives as part of the reason. Drawing on my experience as a PhD researcher, I describe six ways academic incentives misalign with what animal advocates need:
• 1) research questions follow the literature rather than practitioner decision relevance;• 2) health- and climate-motivated research leads to disproportional attention to red meat and neglect of the small animal replacement problem;• 3) research concentrates in a few Western countries because researchers and funders are there;• 4) easily testable interventions crowd out potentially more impactful ones;• 5) collecting real-world behavioral data is costly but not rewarded; and• 6) sharing findings with practitioners earns researchers little.At least some of these incentives seem tractable to change, for instance through new (co-)funding aligned with animal welfare priorities, connecting researchers with animal organizations, and raising the salience of practitioner priorities among researchers.
Context: I am in the later stages of a PhD at Wageningen University, where I study plant-based dietary interventions and their spillover effects in the Netherlands. This post is largely based on my personal experiences and interactions with the academic system. It therefore mostly concerns animal product consumption, but it is likely applicable beyond this (e.g., movement tactics).
IntroductionAs highlighted previously, both on the forum and in the academic literature (forum post), we lack evidence on what reduces animal product consumption. That raises the question of why we have such an evidence problem.
Part of the issue may be that reducing animal product consumption is difficult: most rigorously studied interventions find small effects (Green, Smith & Mathur, 2025), though approaches like plant-based defaults are a positive counterexample (Lohmann et al., 2026). Another part of the problem is that the evide