Description du poste
“Spoiled dogs, sleeping belly-up. No natural predators.”
So says Oliver Quick in Saltburn, describing the wealthy family he has infiltrated. I re-watched it recently and this line made me think of Effective Altruism.
I don’t mean that people in EA are spoiled. I do think, though, that EA’s community norms can lull us into a false sense of comfort, and that this makes it easy for us to lose our way, both through bad decisions and by being manipulated.
I believe incredibly strongly that EA has no particular resistance to the dangers associated with money, status and power. In fact, I think it is unusually vulnerable to them.
These risks will be much more acute during the AI windfall. I think we should take steps now to mitigate them.
What happened last time there was a lot of money?Not going to lie, it wasn’t perfect.
Despite several sincere attempts to get out ahead of it, the EA community took enormous damage, a lot of it self-inflicted.
Among other things, we granted a lot of money that was ultimately clawed back from the recipients; bought a historic abbey, barely used it and later sold it at an enormous loss; and also put someone on a pedestal who turned out to be one of the largest fraudsters of all time (you have probably heard about this one).
There was also other bad behaviour happening at the same time, including serious sexual misconduct issues, which was not obviously linked to the money, but came partly from the same gaps in governance.
The effects of this are still being felt today.
Doesn’t Effective Altruism have antibodies against this stuff?I don’t think so. This view is partly formed from our track record (above) and partly from reasoning (below).
We tend to assume people in EA are impact-oriented, high integrity and both truthful and truth-seeking. Many people in EA have made real sacrifices in service of impact, like giving away a large share of their income.
Assuming this about people we don’t know makes us vulnerable to manipulation. An Oliver