← Toutes les offres
ES

Good Inventions, Not Good Intentions: A Deeper Dive

Elaine Siu

Global
Publié le 16 novembre 2026

Description du poste

What eight stories of animal use ending can tell us about where to place our betsElaine Siu with Paul Shapiro 💁🏻‍♀️: Paul Shapiro has been making an argument for years, in essays and talks and, most recently, in a peer-reviewed commentary with a title that sums it up in a nutshell: “Good inventions, not good intentions: technological displacement of animal use and the drivers of social change.”¹ The argument goes like this: When a category of animal use ended, it almost never ended because people were convinced that it was unethical. It ended because somebody invented something better. Kerosene, not conscience, emptied the whaling docks of New Bedford. Steel nibs, not sympathy for geese, retired the quill. The commentary gathers eight such cases and lands where Paul has landed for many years: those who want to advance animal protection “may need to place greater emphasis on directing resources toward developing and scaling alternatives that can outcompete ethically problematic systems.” I agree with him. I left a legal career ten years ago because I bought this theory of change. I have spent the decade since inside the field it produced, and now, as a PhD researcher, reflecting how the theory has actually worked out in alternative proteins. So when Paul and I started talking after he helped me with one of my recent posts, we found an ideological soulmate in each other (this isn’t an exclusive club, we’re trying to find others with this post!) What follows is what we found when we asked: what other patterns emerge from putting his eight historical cases side by side? The comparison turns up insights, as well as questions, about the factors that enable a new technology to displace an animal product. 💁🏼‍♂️: From here on, “we” means the two of us, though Elaine did nearly all the initial drafting. 💁🏻‍♀️: And Paul did all the arguing thereafter. First, if you don’t read the whole piece, here’s the tl;dr:• Better inventions have ended many uses of animals without