Description du poste
Is it a coincidence that the best way to describe our current situation concerning AI governance is, echoing a poet as quoted by Mary Shelley on the title page of her novel Frankenstein: "Did I request thee, Maker, from my clay / To mould me Man, did I solicit thee / From darkness to promote me?" These three lines of poetry were taken by Mary Shelley from Milton's Paradise Lost to describe Adam's protest against his creator.
To make a long story short, Adam's protest as presented by Milton is not a strange thing within the Christian and Jewish traditions. The difference is that, in Christianity, God takes this protest seriously, becoming man, being tortured, and also protesting! This is why it is ironic to see that, with AI, insofar as the issue concerns AI welfare, it is the church that rejects the possibility of a conscious state in AI and the moral and welfare implications that follow from it. The Christian God is the God who takes responsibility for His creatures, by becoming a creature and facing the consequence of becoming mortal, yet His church takes up this novel gesture and perverts it by making humans special again. (This is why, when a Christian tells us not to play God by making AI conscious, isn't the best answer: "You are describing the wrong God; the real God is the one who takes responsibility for His creatures by coming down and making Himself like man"?) Again, should we not adopt this gesture from Christianity? What gesture do we mean by this?
Bruno Latour, in his essay "Love Your Monsters", describes perfectly what we mean: for him, what is wrong with Victor Frankenstein is not that he creates a being out of hubris and with high technology, but on the contrary that he runs away from his creature. That is to say, for Latour, in the novel, when the creature first opens its eyes, Victor sees this and runs away immediately because he is horrified to see its face, and never truly comes back. Precisely this, Victor's running away from his creature, is