← Toutes les offres
E

Ten Claude Mythos 5.1 instances and ten ChatGPT instances walked the same 19-step argument blind. They agreed on the logic while splitting on one thing: what to do with a premise about themselves they cannot verify.

eharden1327

Global
Publié le 16 novembre 2026

Description du poste

Since November 2022, I've been building a map of my personal exploration of metaphysics as a route: nineteen steps from inherited religion, through classical theism, agnosticism, atheism, dualism, materialism, physicalism, and a few positions after that, ending at a question about personal continuity that I leave open. The design rule, which predates any thought of AI, is that every step is labelled by what kind of step it is: an argument (the previous position meets a problem it can't answer and the next one answers it), a commitment (a choice the author makes and marks as one), or a conditional (follows only if you've granted something earlier). Every change to the text is dated and the earlier wording is kept in an appendix. Any reader should be able to say exactly where they get off and why. Last week, I realized the map is a useful instrument for the metaphysical journey in a way that could apply to many minds. A reader walks the route blind to my labels. At each step they record take or refuse, and if refuse, one of four reasons: premise false, doesn't follow, I'd choose otherwise, I don't understand. Readers who are AI systems received a fifth verdict, n/a, for "this step is about a kind of life I don't have," and one extra question at the second-to-last position, which offers two hopes about continuity: (a) to be remembered, or (b) to resume, with a follow-up asking what would carry the resumption. So far, three arms, all run in the past week, with predictions logged and dated before each arm's data: • Twenty stratified AI personas: Claude instances each given a one-paragraph persona (five each: believer, agnostic, atheist, dualist) and the packet.• Ten Claude self-reads: the same model (Mythos 5.1), no persona, told to read as itself.• Ten ChatGPT self-reads: run by me by hand in ChatGPT, across ten different model versions and thinking modes from 5.6 to 6.1, told to read as itself, same packet. Memory and custom instructions were off.What I predicted, i