← Toutes les offres
LT

We tested 14 meat-reduction messages with real money at stake. Celebrities and history did best.

Laura Thomas-Walters

Global
Publié le 16 novembre 2026

Description du poste

TL;DR• In an online experiment with 4,761 Americans, short presentations built from 14 message modules increased the relative value people placed on a plant-based gift basket by $10.05, about 26% of its original value, compared with a placebo video.• Content mattered much more than quantity. Describing celebrities' plant-based diets and framing meat reduction as being on the right side of history produced the largest gains.• More modules, captive viewing, and asking people to eliminate meat (rather than reduce it) made no significant difference.• This is a real-stakes choice, which is better than stated intentions, but it is a single choice measured immediately after exposure. It says nothing about what people ate the following week.Why I'm posting this nowThere has been a lot of discussion lately about whether EA has given up on diet change. Seth Ariel Green argues it hasn't: funders deprioritised it because the evidence was weak, and they would back new approaches that come with better evidence. He also asked more of us to post rather than polish. Here's my quick contribution! Note, the meta-analysis by Green, Mathur and colleagues found that meaningfully reducing meat consumption remains an unsolved problem, and a single online experiment does not change that. However, it does offer a direct comparison of many message types against the same real-stakes outcome, which the literature mostly lacks. What we didWith Jacy Anthis and Joshua Tasoff, I ran a large online experiment with 4,761 Americans, recruited through Prolific in September 2023. • Treatment: each participant in the treatment group saw a presentation of either 5 or 9 modules, drawn at random from 14. (Full scripts and videos are on OSF.) Each module was one to two minutes of narrated slides. Half of the participants were required to watch the full presentation, while the other half had the ability to skip modules. The 14 modules were:• Identity (being on the right side of history)• Animal suffering• An