Description du poste
EDIT: removed claims that FarmKind's main ToC is offsets. This is not true (see Aidans comment below).
As far as I'm aware, most people feel carbon offsetting largely hasn't worked. Does that mean offsetting meat consumption is a dead-end?
I argue no. If we look at the 2 main reasons why carbon offsetting has failed to reach it's potential, we can see that meat offsetting does not have these problems. As a result, meat offsetting may be an effective strategy to reduce animal suffering.
Caveat before we beginHere I am discussing a very narrow question, which is whether the failure of carbon offsets tells us that meat offsets will not work. There are wider debates to be had around meat offsetting, such as whether it is morally permissible. I’m not commenting on that here, and I’ve seen good arguments on both sides.
This should also not be taken as an endorsement of FarmKind’s “Forget Veganuary” campaign they ran earlier this year. Evaluating that campaign involves a lot more than just offsetting, and I have nuanced thoughts about it that I won’t go into here. However, as FarmKind does have a tool that allows people to offset their consumption, this post can be taken as a defence of the idea behind that.
1. Most carbon offsetting companies are basically scamsSummarised here. Problems included:
• Offsetting companies promising to protect rainforest from deforestation, but then simply sending the logger to cut down the forest next door.• Offsetting companies selling “protection” of rainforest that had 0 chance of being cut down anyway.• Offsetting companies inflating their impact by as much as 10 times.Meat offsets are less vulnerable to scamsThis scam risk does not apply to meat offsetting, at least in the case of FarmKind. they send offsetting donations go to 3rd party evaluated organisations that I am very confident do reduce demand for meat or reduce animal suffering or both. See them here. Similarly, FarmKind themselves are not conducting the evaluations. They are r