← Toutes les offres
JC

Surplus and profit: rethinking unfairness

James Chang

Global
Publié le 18 novembre 2026

Description du poste

People around me sometimes complain that quant firms get paid a lot while contributing little (some even claim negative) to the world. I also sense the "unfairness", but it's pretty hard to actually explain how that feeling arises. In this post, I try to describe a hypothesis on where that feeling comes from, and argue that big tech and frontier labs have their own versions of it, which some people also complain is "unfair". I don't have a finished theory. What I have is one idea and three places where I see it. Profit as a proxyCapitalism works well partly because profit is a decent proxy for contribution. Profit originates from making something people value more than it costs (i.e. "surplus"), and you keep some of it as profit. Usually you keep only a small part, and the rest goes to customers or society. Nordhaus (2004) estimated that innovators in the US captured only about 2% of the total value their innovations created. From this point of view, people might feel it is unfair if the above is not true. I see at least two main ways things could go wrong: • The firm keeps an unusually large share of the surplus it creates.• The firm causes harms or uses inputs it doesn't pay for.1. Apple farmer as the base caseI like to use apple farmers as an illustration of what people would normally expect about a business's contribution and its profit. To the best of my knowledge, the grower gets roughly 25–30% of the retail price, and has to pay for land and labor, making it barely profitable and volatile. (The grocer isn't getting rich either: US supermarkets keep about 1–2% of sales as net profit.) Since people are willing to pay the retail price, we can infer that the surplus of creating the apple is at least that much (minus the cost), and in fact that is just a lower bound, since we can expect the customer's average willingness to pay to be higher than the price (where the gap is the average consumer surplus). So, almost all the value of an apple ends up with the person