← Toutes les offres
KT

Where is all the AI persuasion?

Karthik Tadepalli

Global
Publié le 18 novembre 2026

Description du poste

Persuasive AI is one of the classic AI risk scenarios. If AIs can talk people into believing or doing things they wouldn’t otherwise believe or do, that could seriously threaten elections and democratic institutions. In more dramatic scenarios, it’s a threat to human control over AI itself: before an AI can act in the world on its own, it could convince humans to act on its behalf. We now have a growing pile of studies that tell us AIs are now extremely persuasive, more so than expert humans. But does persuasion in a study setting translate into real-world persuasion? It turns out the answer is no. That gap matters beyond persuasion. The critical question today is whether AI progress on checkable tasks will generalize to fuzzy tasks. Because fuzzy tasks are by definition hard to evaluate, we have very little evidence to go off of. Persuasion is a rare fuzzy domain where we can actually check evaluations against real-world evidence. Whether AI progress extends to the fuzzy parts of real-world persuasion can tell us whether to expect it to extend to fuzzy tasks in other domains, like AI research. So: where is all the AI persuasion? On paper, frontier AIs are superhuman at persuasionA long line of research has shown that AIs are frighteningly persuasive. Most recently, in June 2026, the UK AI Security Institute released a study in which frontier models were matched up against champion debaters and expert political canvassers to see who was better at changing people’s minds in text conversations. Across nearly 20,000 conversations on policy issues, AIs moved people’s views about 5 points more than the elite debaters and professional canvassers did. They even got people to give more real money to charity. The bottom line was that the best AIs now out-persuade the best humans we can find. In another study, researchers had AIs talk with voters ahead of the 2024-25 American, Canadian and Polish national elections to see whether they could change minds in a high-stakes elec