Description du poste
Some say one-half, others one third, still others ask that we define "which event" we are trying to examine. In my piece about the Sleeping Beauty problem, I go against all three.
I argue that the question is indeed ambiguous, but not in the sense claimed by the standard critique. Building an argument step-by-step to avoid the frequent confusion about language that plagues discussions of probability matters, I propose an alternative approach to disambiguation and lay out the simple math that describes the situation. Along the way, I explain why the most common challenge to the thirder position is a non-starter and why the solution feels unsatisfactory. But uneasy as it may feel, the answer stands before our eyes. If any disagreements still remain, they are semantic in nature -- just different opinions about the way to employ terms like "credence," which can never be settled by running the numbers.
Article: https://tinyurl.com/SleepingBeautyDT
Video: https://tinyurl.com/SleepingBeautyVideoDT