Description du poste
I would like our public spaces to be more beautiful and comfortable. So would some other guys on the internet, but to me they seem pretty confused about the root cause of why they're ugly now.
Patrick Collison, for example, ponders:
Many things today are ugly and far uglier than they used to be or need to be. Once you see this, it’s kinda hard to stop perceiving it. (Early twentieth century phone boxes versus modern phone boxes; old water fountains versus new water fountains; etc.) As someone with a naively meliorist assumption that most things should be getting better rather than worse, it’s all a bit perplexing: why did we stop doing things nicely? Is it a choice? Was there a malevolent spell cast upon us?
At the end of his x post on this subject he appears to imply that this ugliness might be a marker of modern western culture's underlying metaphysical incoherence?
The illustrative example he provides is of two telephone booths, one strikingly red and beautiful and one black and utilitarian.
This is not a level 1 discourse topic. I know this because sometimes I am linked articles that are titled things like "Eight architecture myths BUSTED by Samuel Hughes" (a piece written, perhaps confusingly, by Ben Southwood), where you can infer from the title a whole universe of discourse where there are narratives and counter-narratives about modern architecture.
People who discoursepoast about this topic seem to really insist on the fact that there is in fact such a thing as spaces that are more objectively beautiful and humane, which, yes agreed, but they seem to think that the reason that things are ugly now is because there's some sort of... evil elite degeneracy or counter-signalling? Okay, um, straight off the bat here are some problems I notice with this hypothesis:
• If you go to places where only the evil elites gather, such as Michelin star fine dining restaurants, too-fancy hotel bars like the one where I paid $47 US dollars 😔 for a whiskey sour, Google offices