Description du poste
Subtitle: if you truly believed that...
Every once in a while, I encounter what I call the idiot’s reductio: “If you truly believed X, you’d do Y. Since you don’t do Y, you must not actually believe X.”
A special case is when people say “I don’t believe in/feel/have X. But if you truly did believe in X, you’d do a crazy and absurd thing. Since you don’t do this crazy and absurd thing, I conclude you don’t believe in X, and also X isn’t real.”
Almost always incredibly childish and a complete failure of theory of mind. Some examples:
• If you actually believed in the Christian Bible, you’d avoid wearing mixed fibers. Therefore you’re a fake Christian and you should either be an atheist or believe in my specific flavor of liberal Christianity with no controversial components.• God is the only reason for human morality. If not for Christianity, people would murder their neighbors all the time. Therefore your atheism is fake and the Christian God is real.• If you actually thought abortion was murder, you’d firebomb a Walmart, and hold funerals for miscarriages. You haven’t firebombed a Walmart. QED.• If you actually thought factory farming is evil, you’d firebomb a Walmart.• If you actually believed in climate change, you’d firebomb a Walmart.• If you actually believed in AI doom, you’d firebomb a Walmart.• If Al Gore really believed in climate change, he wouldn’t fly to climate change conferences and would, I dunno, swim or something.• If you really believed in open borders, you’d leave your front door unlocked and house migrants yourself.• Erika Kirk does speeches and sometimes laughs on camera in interviews. Therefore, she’s not actually sad about her husband dying. Also the death was faked.• “She called her alleged rapist the day after, therefore she wasn’t raped.”• “If you actually believed in Communism you wouldn’t be using an iPhone”• “If Ayn Rand was a real capitalist, she wouldn’t take welfare”• When Jacob Coxon quit Anthropic to warn the world about AI doom, he