← Toutes les offres
WV

Should Parents Genetically Engineer Their Children?

Walter Veit

Global
Publié le 21 novembre 2026

Description du poste

This is a crosspost from my Substack. Imagine a world where everyone is healthy, intelligent, long living and happy. Intuitively this seems wonderful, albeit unrealistic. However, recent scientific developments in genetic engineering, namely CRISPR/Cas bring the question into public discourse, how the genetic enhancement of humans should be evaluated morally. From my article “Procreative Beneficence and Genetic Enhancement” (2018, p. 75) Image: National Human Genome Research Institute, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)In 2018, a Chinese doctor was highly criticised for using CRISPR on two twin girls. Procreative BeneficenceInterestingly, a similar debate unfolded in 2001, when in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) enabled parents to choose between multiple ‘artificially’ created embryos. Julian Savulescu, a bioethicist at Oxford, introduced the ‘Principle of Procreative Beneficence’ (PPB) arguing that parents are, in fact, obligated to choose among these embryos the one that is expected to have the best life.[1] The article containing this argument has become one of the most cited in the literature and has caused much controversy, especially among religious communities and disability rights activists. An eight-cell human embryo, the stage at which cells were classically removed for preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Image: ekem, RWJMS IVF Program, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)Some countries, such as Germany, even banned the creation of multiple embryos, eliminating the choice problem parents could be faced with. While religious communities argued that such a choice does not respect human dignity and the value of each human being, disability rights advocates argued that this would lead to discrimination, suggesting that humans born with genetic defects are worth less than others. Naturally, this raised unwelcome associations with the Nazi eugenics programme, where people with disabilities were sterilised against their wi