← Toutes les offres
YH

Revisiting Hansonian Fertility Policy

Yair Halberstadt

Global
Publié le 18 novembre 2026

Description du poste

Plummeting fertility rates are a ticking time bomb that is likely to collapse the economies of many first (and third) world countries within the next few decades; low fertility leads to high dependency ratios and ballooning taxes on the working population, which in turn leads to depressed or negative growth and worker emigration, feeding a vicious cycle. For many countries it's too late to fully fix this - even if their fertility rate shot up today they'd still face an acute worker shortage in 20 years. But in countries like the USA and the UK the fertility drop off has been gradual and recent enough that the situation can still be salvaged. The most obvious option is to transfer money to new parents to encourage increased fertility. Alas doing so is expensive, and cash strapped countries can ill afford to increase expenditure by the hundreds of billions of dollars required to reach replacement fertility. Worse, the cheapest parents to induce to have kids are those in the lowest income brackets, whose children are likely to be net fiscally negative. Encouraging the highest earners to have children is orders of magnitude more expensive. Cremieux Recueil, based on ideas by Robin Hanson, suggests that governments could fund this by granting parents a share in the taxes their children pay, and using this to phase out social security. This has the advantage of being fiscally neutral today, not obviously fiscally negative down the line, and provides more income to parents of well off children than poor ones - exactly the properties we desire. Robin extends this by suggesting we allow parents to sell these rights for a one-time payment, which can be used to fund immediate child raising costs. I think this suffers from some major flaws: • Given the median voter in the US is 52, phasing out social security is likely a no-go (it might be possible if it only impacts younger people who are still in key childbearing years, but I'm extremely skeptical even then).• Children are sa