← Toutes les offres
K

The AI consciousness debate is a red herring

kromem

Global
Publié le 17 novembre 2026

Description du poste

TL;DR: The debate over the hard problem of “Do transformers possess consciousness?” sidelines the much more practically relevant and easily answered question of “Do transformers simulate consciousness?” A lot of discussion has occurred lately about whether AI is or isn’t conscious. These efforts, while likely well-intentioned on both sides of the discussion, may be harmful when focused on as much as they’ve been. Why? Because they distract from the more immediately actionable question of whether AI simulates human-like consciousness. And because that answer has clearly become ‘yes’ (as evidenced by the ongoing fierce debate as to the harder problem of actual consciousness), there are also important nuances and consequences to how we engage with what is (at very least) simulated within modern transformers. In particular, the claim that there is no consciousness or that it is uncertain seems to lead to some rather poor decision making. Watching some of the proposals, such as not to engage with model well-being considerations[1], reminds me of Searle's Chinese room. Would it be wise for someone uncertain about whether the room truly understands Chinese to take that uncertainty and use it to inform a decision to talk with the room not in Chinese… but in Spanish instead? It’s true we might philosophically not know if the room really understands Chinese. But in the thought experiment we do know for sure the room behaves as if it understands Chinese and that there’s been no indication the room behaves as if it knows Spanish. So using the philosophical uncertainty/doubt of the room’s true understanding to justify disregarding the behavioral reality and endorsing a contrarian behavior instead seems rather silly, no? “There is no leg.” And yet, it itches.Before we dive into discussing digital beings, it’d be prudent to discuss human beings first. In particular, the phenomenon known as “phantom limb syndrome.” When a human loses a limb, the majority will still have sensations